Nolan Wells’ Family Seeks Federal Review After Grand Jury Declines Charges

Nolan Wells’ family is calling for federal authorities to reexamine his death as both autopsies leave the cause and manner undetermined.

Nolan Wells’ family is renewing its push for a federal investigation after a Mississippi grand jury declined to indict anyone in his death. At an October 5 news conference in Inglewood, California, his parents and attorney Ben Crump called for another examination of the case that has drawn months of public scrutiny.

Wells, an 18-year-old college football player, disappeared during a Fourth of July boating trip to Horn Island. His body was recovered on July 6. Investigators initially suspected drowning, while his family continued to question what happened after the group traveled to the island.

“We have been left with more questions and heartbreak than any answers,” his mother, Christine Wonsley, said, according to ABC News. Wells was Black and Filipino American. Stop AAPI Hate executive director Cynthia Choi joined the family and Crump at the news conference and supported their request for federal intervention.

The medical findings remain central to the family’s concerns. The state medical examiner’s report classifies both the cause and manner of death as undetermined. It records two bruises beneath the scalp at the back of Wells’ head, with no skull fractures or other external or internal injuries. Its conclusion cites the unknown circumstances surrounding his death. Those findings do not establish who, if anyone, caused the bruising.

In a September statement, the family’s legal team said independent pathologist Dr. Roger A. Mitchell Jr. also concluded that the cause and manner were undetermined. The attorneys argued that the head injuries and their possible contribution to Wells’ death had not been adequately explained. They called for the investigation to remain active and for the investigative file to be released.

Watch: ABC News: Nolan Wells’ family releases state autopsy report (September 25, 2026).

The grand jury reached its decision after hearing 43 witnesses and reviewing physical, digital and forensic evidence, including reports from the family’s phone examiner. Its redacted report, made public in September, found no credible evidence that people who traveled to or from Horn Island on the group’s three boats committed a crime related to Wells’ death. It described the recovery circumstances as “consistent with drowning” and said neither pathologist had ruled out accidental drowning.

The panel unanimously returned a No True Bill, a decision against an indictment. This was a charging determination, not a verdict issued after a criminal trial. The report also says credible future evidence suggesting a non-accidental death should be presented to a grand jury for further consideration.

The family’s request follows an August appeal from the Congressional Black Caucus for an independent federal review and an assessment of whether a federal investigation was warranted. The caucus said federal involvement should help establish the facts without prejudging the outcome. At the time, the Justice Department told ABC News it had received the letter and was reviewing it.

Reviewing a request does not itself confirm that an independent investigation has opened. ABC reported on October 5 that the FBI, Justice Department and National Park Service had not immediately responded to its requests for comment on the family’s latest appeal.

Read the document: The Congressional Black Caucus’s August 12 request for federal review (PDF).

Public commentary has also produced a separate legal dispute. The Associated Press reported October 6 that three of Wells’ friends sued former NFL star Terrell Owens for defamation over a social-media post calling for their arrest. The complaint contains allegations, and AP said Owens had not immediately responded to its efforts to reach him. That civil lawsuit is separate from the investigation into Wells’ death.

For now, the family is asking federal authorities to take another look. Any announcement of additional investigative action or credible new evidence would mark a substantive next step in a case whose medical cause of death remains undetermined.

NewsNation: “Nolan Wells case: New evidence and legal fight put investigation back in focus | Backscroll.”


Also check out Cyclolore Magazine’s new DOSSIER Mining Issue & other publications we’ve released below!

 
 

Related Stories to read next from this featured panel!